Tuesday, August 31, 2010
Thursday, August 26, 2010
Europe and the People Without History by Eric Wolf.
Europe and the People Without History is a book by anthropologist Eric Wolf. First published in 1982, it focuses on the expansion of European societies in the Modern Era. It argues that this expansion affected both the societies that Europeans encountered in their expansion and European societies themselves. It asserts that non-European peoples were active participants in the progress of history, rather than static, unchanging cultures. The assumption that these 'others' are from unchanging cultures, and are left out of Eurocentric historical narratives is why they are referred to as 'people without history'. The "People Without History" also refers to those peoples of whom their cultures lack a formally written articulation of their histories hindering their inclusion in 'Western' historical narratives.
Tuesday, August 24, 2010
Some of Albert Einstein's Quotes...
"Any intelligent fool can make things bigger, more complex, and more violent. It takes a touch of genius -- and a lot of courage -- to move in the opposite direction."
"Not everything that counts can be counted, and not everything that can be counted counts." (Sign hanging in Einstein's office at Princeton)
"Whoever undertakes to set himself up as a judge of Truth and Knowledge is shipwrecked by the laughter of the gods."
"Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the the universe."
"The important thing is not to stop questioning. Curiosity has its own reason for existing."
"Education is what remains after one has forgotten everything he learned in school."
"Great spirits have often encountered violent opposition from weak minds."
"Weakness of attitude becomes weakness of character."
"Imagination is more important than knowledge."
Albert Einstein
"Not everything that counts can be counted, and not everything that can be counted counts." (Sign hanging in Einstein's office at Princeton)
"Whoever undertakes to set himself up as a judge of Truth and Knowledge is shipwrecked by the laughter of the gods."
"Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the the universe."
"The important thing is not to stop questioning. Curiosity has its own reason for existing."
"Education is what remains after one has forgotten everything he learned in school."
"Great spirits have often encountered violent opposition from weak minds."
"Weakness of attitude becomes weakness of character."
"Imagination is more important than knowledge."
Albert Einstein
Monday, August 23, 2010
Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds
“Men, it has been well said, think in herds; it will be seen that they go mad in herds, while they only recover their senses slowly, one by one.”
Scottish historian Charles Mackay.
Scottish historian Charles Mackay.
Saturday, August 21, 2010
Wednesday, August 18, 2010
Mahommah Gardo Baquaqua
Born in Djougou (in modern Benin) around 1830, Baquaqua was captured in a local war and shipped out through the Dahomian port of Whydah as part of the illegal trans-Atlantic slave trade. Arriving in Brazil, he began life as a slave in Pernambuco and was subsequently sold to a sea captain from Rio de Janeiro. In 1847 he escaped with the help of free black abolitionists while the ship was docked in New York City and spent two years in the free black Republic of Haiti with the American Baptist Free Mission Society. With the support of the mission society, he attended New York Central College in upstate New York from 1850 to 1853 and published his autobiography the following year.
Baquaqua's story is significant for several reasons. First, it gives a detailed account (comprising over half the text) of life and conditions in his home region before his enslavement. This section is written in the third person, probably by his editor Samuel Moore, based on information supplied by Baquaqua. Once Baquaqua is captured, however, the narrative switches to a first-person account. Second, Baquaqua's story is unusual in that his travels took him from Whydah to Brazil, the United States, Canada, and Haiti, thus illustrating the wide reach of the trans-Atlantic slave trade and New World slavery. As Lovejoy writes, Baquaqua was a man of the Black Adantic.
Originally published in 2001, the edited book has now come out in a revised and expanded second edition. A model for the editing of historical texts, the book contains a biographical introduction that is almost as long as the narrative itself, with extensive footnotes, four maps, twenty-seven illustrations, a glossary, a bibliography, and five appendixes containing letters written by Baquaqua and other source material.
Robert Harms
Yale University
New Haven, Connecticut
Baquaqua's story is significant for several reasons. First, it gives a detailed account (comprising over half the text) of life and conditions in his home region before his enslavement. This section is written in the third person, probably by his editor Samuel Moore, based on information supplied by Baquaqua. Once Baquaqua is captured, however, the narrative switches to a first-person account. Second, Baquaqua's story is unusual in that his travels took him from Whydah to Brazil, the United States, Canada, and Haiti, thus illustrating the wide reach of the trans-Atlantic slave trade and New World slavery. As Lovejoy writes, Baquaqua was a man of the Black Adantic.
Originally published in 2001, the edited book has now come out in a revised and expanded second edition. A model for the editing of historical texts, the book contains a biographical introduction that is almost as long as the narrative itself, with extensive footnotes, four maps, twenty-seven illustrations, a glossary, a bibliography, and five appendixes containing letters written by Baquaqua and other source material.
Robert Harms
Yale University
New Haven, Connecticut
Sunday, August 8, 2010
Tuesday, August 3, 2010
SOCNET
Understanding social networks within complex, nonlinear systems: geographically-integrated history and dynamics GIS.
Sunday, August 1, 2010
Tuesday, July 27, 2010
Choosing a Project of Life
Life is at the same time fate and freedom, and that freedom “is being free inside of a given fate. Fate gives us an inexorable repertory of determinate possibilities, that is, it gives us different destinies. We accept fate and within it we choose one destiny.” In this tied down fate we must therefore be active, decide and create a “project of life”—thus not be like those who live a conventional life of customs and given structures who prefer an unconcerned and imperturbable life because they are afraid of the duty of choosing a project. José Ortega y Gasset
Sunday, July 4, 2010
The Spatial Humanities: GIS and the Future of Humanities Scholarship.
"Space -- whether it be the space of the choreographer's dance floor, the artist's canvas, or the religious shrine -- has always been important to humanist scholarship. But in recent years a virtual explosion of new data, tools, and concepts has revolutionized our ability to examine the relationships, patterns, and contexts that emerge when the human world is examined through a spatial lens. This book brings these ideas into focus for the first time, presenting a cornucopia of ideas, examples, methods, and suggestions for further reading that will be invaluable to anyone seeking to adopt a spatial approach to humanist scholarship, or to understand why it has attracted so much recent attention." -- Michael F. Goodchild, University of California, Santa Barbara.
Friday, July 2, 2010
The New Brazil
"The New Brazil" tells the story of that nation's evolution from a remote Portuguese colony into a regional leader, a respected spokesman for the developing world, and an increasingly important partner for the United States and the European Union. For much of the twentieth century, Brazil seemed mired in perpetual economic crisis. Today prudent fiscal and monetary policies have yielded high levels of foreign direct investment and an investment-grade rating for its debt. Brazil is also emerging as an energy powerhouse, and policymakers are increasingly confronting the challenge of reducing poverty among tens of millions of people. In this engaging book, Riordan Roett traces the long road Brazil has traveled to reach its present status and discusses the many challenges it has overcome and those that lie ahead. Roett, a veteran scholar and writer on Brazil, discusses the country's development as a colony, empire, and finally a republic; the making of modern Brazil, beginning with the rise to power of Getulio Vargas in 1930; the advent of military government in 1964; the return to civilian rule two decades later; and the pivotal presidencies of Fernando Henrique Cardoso and Luis Inacio Lula da Silva. As Brazil prepares to elect a new president in October 2010, much remains to be done to consolidate and expand the country's global role. Nonetheless, as an important player on the world stage, Brazil is here to stay.
About the Author
Riordan Roett is the Sarita and Don Johnston Professor of Political Science and director of Western Hemisphere Studies and the Latin American Studies program at the Paul H. Nitze School of Advanced International Studies (SAIS), Johns Hopkins University.Brazil on the Rise
A RICH AND REVEALING PORTRAIT OF A COUNTRY ON THE CUTTING EDGE
An alluring land famous for samba, soccer, supermodels, and stunning tropical beaches, Brazil was described as “paradise on earth” by its first Portuguese explorers. Its annual Carnival is known the world over for its Dionysian revelry, and its Amazon rainforest is considered one of the planet’s most precious resources. Yet nature’s gifts have not always spelled national prosperity: two decades ago Brazil had a crippling debt and was emerging from a military dictatorship that censored journalists and oppressed dissenters. Today Brazil is not only the world’s eighth largest economy with a vibrant democracy; it has achieved energy independence, and its discovery of the largest oil field thus far this century should soon make it a major energy exporter. With its successful bid as host for the 2016 Olympics and the soccer World Cup in 2014, Brazil is at last ready to take its place on the global stage. What led to the transformation?
In this rich and textured account, New York Times reporter Larry Rohter gives us the definitive look at the country’s amazing rebirth. As the paper’s bureau chief in Rio, Rohter had a front-row seat for many of the dramatic changes that have unfolded in Brazil in recent years. Through interviews with every important political, business, cultural, and religious leader on the scene, Rohter delivers a sharp and fresh account of the country’s rapid and radical changes, uncovering:
An alluring land famous for samba, soccer, supermodels, and stunning tropical beaches, Brazil was described as “paradise on earth” by its first Portuguese explorers. Its annual Carnival is known the world over for its Dionysian revelry, and its Amazon rainforest is considered one of the planet’s most precious resources. Yet nature’s gifts have not always spelled national prosperity: two decades ago Brazil had a crippling debt and was emerging from a military dictatorship that censored journalists and oppressed dissenters. Today Brazil is not only the world’s eighth largest economy with a vibrant democracy; it has achieved energy independence, and its discovery of the largest oil field thus far this century should soon make it a major energy exporter. With its successful bid as host for the 2016 Olympics and the soccer World Cup in 2014, Brazil is at last ready to take its place on the global stage. What led to the transformation?
In this rich and textured account, New York Times reporter Larry Rohter gives us the definitive look at the country’s amazing rebirth. As the paper’s bureau chief in Rio, Rohter had a front-row seat for many of the dramatic changes that have unfolded in Brazil in recent years. Through interviews with every important political, business, cultural, and religious leader on the scene, Rohter delivers a sharp and fresh account of the country’s rapid and radical changes, uncovering:
- As Brazil continues its meteoric rise, this is an authoritative guide to understanding a country that will be a major player on the world stage in the years ahead.
Saturday, June 26, 2010
Livraria Cultura in Fortaleza
Today I visited Livraria Cultura in Fortaleza and loved it. I purchased an interesting book by Varnhagen about the Dutch in Brazil (1624-1654).
Wednesday, June 23, 2010
Gustavo Barroso
While visiting my family in Brazil this summer, I came across a most interesting writer, Gustavo Barroso, born in Fortaleza in 1888. Here I will post some of my favorite passages.
“Meu pai começa a caminhar, levando-me pela mão para casa e concluindo:
- Os nomes das ruas duma cidade, meu filho, refletem a sua vida e resumem a sua história. É um erro, senão mesmo um crime, mudá-los a cada passo, sobretudo para homenagear individualidades passageiras. Destrói-se a tradição que deve ser sagrada, porque é a alma duma Pátria. Não póde haver Pátria sem tradição.” (p. 25) Coração de Menino by Gustavo Barroso.
Monday, June 14, 2010
Saturday, May 22, 2010
This summer (2010) I am reading Thomas Merton, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, and St. Ignatius of Loyola. I will be posting here some of my favorite pessages. Here are some excerpts from No Man is an Island by Thomas Merton:
"A happiness that is sought for ourselves alone can never be found: for a happiness that is diminished by being shared is not big enough to make us happy."
"There is a false and momentary happiness in self-satisfaction, but it always leads to sorrow because it narrows and deadens our spirit. True happiness is found in unselfish love, a love which increases in proportion as it is shared. There is no end to the sharing of love, and, therefore, the potential happiness of such love is without limit. Infinite sharing is the law of God's inner life. He has made the sharing of ourselves the law of our own being, so that it is in loving others that we best love ourselves. In disinterested activity we best fulfill our own capacities to act and to be."
"Yet there can never be happiness in compulsion. It is not enough for love to be shared: it must be shared freely. That is to say it must be given, not merely taken. Unselfish love that is poured out upon a selfish object does not bring perfect happiness: not because love requires a return or a reward for loving, but because it rests in the happiness of the beloved. And if the one loved receives love selfishly, the lover is not satisfied. He sees that his love has failed to make the beloved happy. It has not awakened his capacity for unselfish love."
"Hence the paradox that unselfish love cannot rest perfectly except in a love that is perfectly reciprocated: because it knows that the only true peace is found in selfless love. Selfless love consents to be loved selflessly for the sake of the beloved. In so doing, it perfects itself."
"The gift of love is the gift of the power and the capacity to love, and, therefore, to give love with full effect is also to receive it. So, love can only be kept by being given away, and it can only be given perfectly when it is also received."
-- Thomas Merton
"A happiness that is sought for ourselves alone can never be found: for a happiness that is diminished by being shared is not big enough to make us happy."
"There is a false and momentary happiness in self-satisfaction, but it always leads to sorrow because it narrows and deadens our spirit. True happiness is found in unselfish love, a love which increases in proportion as it is shared. There is no end to the sharing of love, and, therefore, the potential happiness of such love is without limit. Infinite sharing is the law of God's inner life. He has made the sharing of ourselves the law of our own being, so that it is in loving others that we best love ourselves. In disinterested activity we best fulfill our own capacities to act and to be."
"Yet there can never be happiness in compulsion. It is not enough for love to be shared: it must be shared freely. That is to say it must be given, not merely taken. Unselfish love that is poured out upon a selfish object does not bring perfect happiness: not because love requires a return or a reward for loving, but because it rests in the happiness of the beloved. And if the one loved receives love selfishly, the lover is not satisfied. He sees that his love has failed to make the beloved happy. It has not awakened his capacity for unselfish love."
"Hence the paradox that unselfish love cannot rest perfectly except in a love that is perfectly reciprocated: because it knows that the only true peace is found in selfless love. Selfless love consents to be loved selflessly for the sake of the beloved. In so doing, it perfects itself."
"The gift of love is the gift of the power and the capacity to love, and, therefore, to give love with full effect is also to receive it. So, love can only be kept by being given away, and it can only be given perfectly when it is also received."
-- Thomas Merton
Monday, May 17, 2010
Thursday, May 13, 2010
The essence of optimism
The essence of optimism is that it takes no account of the present, but it is a source of inspiration, of vitality and hope where others have resigned; it enables a person to hold his/her head high, to claim the future for himself/herself and not to abandon it.
-- Dietrich Bonhoeffer.
-- Dietrich Bonhoeffer.
Sunday, May 9, 2010
Thursday, April 29, 2010
Tuesday, April 27, 2010
Monday, April 26, 2010
Thursday, April 22, 2010
Mastering the Earth
The story of how the Germans attempted to control their environment, told by David Blackbourn in his book The Conquest of Nature, is similar to many other environmental histories that took place in other parts of the globe. Johann Gottfried Tulla, the engineer known as the father of the modern Rhine, reminded me of William Mulholland, chief engineer and general manager of the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, the man who brought water from the Owens Valley, in California, into Los Angeles, in 1913. It seems to me that human history repeats itself. Owens Valley was once an area filled with orchards and fields and people who live there today still talk about the old days before Mulholland’s project turned their valley into a desert. Similarly, according to Blackbourn’s account, around the 1900, after Tulla had remade the Upper Rhine, one would find the great naturalist Robert Lauterborn deploring the losses of fauna and flora of his beloved river in Germany much like his predecessors, who had told stories about a world which had been lost. These accounts show that there was some longing for the Upper Rhine region prior to Tulla’s project as well as for the Owens Valley prior to the construction of the Los Angeles Aqueduct.
Apparently both, Tulla and Mulholland, had bought into Jeremy Bentham ’s philosophy of utilitarianism at the time. Bentham coined the phrase “the greatest good for the greatest number.” Tulla and Mulholland were most likely thinking of the greatest good for the greatest number of people when they carried out their projects. Utilitarianism was at the forefront of many projects that dealt with natural resources. It is said that Gifford Pinchot, the first man in charge of the newly created Forest Service in the United States, also adhered to this belief. He even added a few words to Bentham’s phrase in his mission statement. He supposedly wrote: “Where conflicting interests must be reconciled, the question shall always be answered from the standpoint of the greatest good of the greatest number in the long run.”
Neither Tulla nor Mulholland anticipated the consequences of their projects. They were both attempts to control nature, which had losses and benefits that are hard to unscramble (to use one of Blackbourn’s word). Nature was an adversary that could be tamed and conquered and humans had the ingenuity to do so. They had at their side an extraordinary ally: science. Blackbourn explains that the emphasis on science in the 19th century was typical of the age. The notion of progress was embraced not only by physical and natural sciences, but also by humanities and social sciences. During the 19th century anthropologists were embracing cultural evolutionism. The English philosopher Herbert Spencer (1820 – 1903) had coined the term “cultural evolutionism”, which envisioned human societies as evolving along a common track from simple to complex. For Spencer, a contemporary of Charles Darwin, evolution pervaded the inorganic as well as the organic realm. In England, Edward Burnett Tylor published Primitive Culture (1871), and, in the United States, Lewis Henry Morgan published Ancient Society (1877), both adopting cultural evolutionism as their theoretical framework. Thus, the taming of the Rhine, the construction of canals, dams, shipyards, harbors, and railways in Germany in the late 19th century and early 20th century took place within a context that favored human beings mastering the Earth and controlling nature. This “outburst of cultural confidence” is what Blackbourn calls “imperialism of imagination” (177). Being intimidated by nature meant going backwards at a time when the notion of progress was interviewed with the belief that human culture was on a path forward (cultural evolution), an ethnocentric framework that most certainly validated all these projects to control nature. The right path to take was to evolve forward, which meant many things, including mastering the Earth.
--
Neda Bezerra
Geographically-Integrated History Laboratory
Historical Resources Management
Idaho State University
Pocatello, ID.
Apparently both, Tulla and Mulholland, had bought into Jeremy Bentham ’s philosophy of utilitarianism at the time. Bentham coined the phrase “the greatest good for the greatest number.” Tulla and Mulholland were most likely thinking of the greatest good for the greatest number of people when they carried out their projects. Utilitarianism was at the forefront of many projects that dealt with natural resources. It is said that Gifford Pinchot, the first man in charge of the newly created Forest Service in the United States, also adhered to this belief. He even added a few words to Bentham’s phrase in his mission statement. He supposedly wrote: “Where conflicting interests must be reconciled, the question shall always be answered from the standpoint of the greatest good of the greatest number in the long run.”
Neither Tulla nor Mulholland anticipated the consequences of their projects. They were both attempts to control nature, which had losses and benefits that are hard to unscramble (to use one of Blackbourn’s word). Nature was an adversary that could be tamed and conquered and humans had the ingenuity to do so. They had at their side an extraordinary ally: science. Blackbourn explains that the emphasis on science in the 19th century was typical of the age. The notion of progress was embraced not only by physical and natural sciences, but also by humanities and social sciences. During the 19th century anthropologists were embracing cultural evolutionism. The English philosopher Herbert Spencer (1820 – 1903) had coined the term “cultural evolutionism”, which envisioned human societies as evolving along a common track from simple to complex. For Spencer, a contemporary of Charles Darwin, evolution pervaded the inorganic as well as the organic realm. In England, Edward Burnett Tylor published Primitive Culture (1871), and, in the United States, Lewis Henry Morgan published Ancient Society (1877), both adopting cultural evolutionism as their theoretical framework. Thus, the taming of the Rhine, the construction of canals, dams, shipyards, harbors, and railways in Germany in the late 19th century and early 20th century took place within a context that favored human beings mastering the Earth and controlling nature. This “outburst of cultural confidence” is what Blackbourn calls “imperialism of imagination” (177). Being intimidated by nature meant going backwards at a time when the notion of progress was interviewed with the belief that human culture was on a path forward (cultural evolution), an ethnocentric framework that most certainly validated all these projects to control nature. The right path to take was to evolve forward, which meant many things, including mastering the Earth.
--
Neda Bezerra
Geographically-Integrated History Laboratory
Historical Resources Management
Idaho State University
Pocatello, ID.
Tuesday, April 20, 2010
AVATAR
This past December, a week before Christmas, 20th Century Fox released a science fiction film that would become the biggest box office of all times: Avatar. I have never been a science fiction buff and the only science fiction I had ever enjoyed was the Bionic Woman, a TV series of the late 1970s. Thus, I never planned to see Avatar, but a teenager, son of a good friend of mine, who was visiting town, insisted that I take him to see it. After thirty three years of the release of the Bionic Woman on TV, there I was, watching for the first time a 21st century science fiction film. I was soon struck by the plot, which carried an environmental message. Some have argued that James Cameron’s Avatar is without a doubt the most epic piece of environmental advocacy ever captured on celluloid. Cameron, the director, told the British newspaper the Sun :
"The point is that we are devastating habitat and biodiversity at a terrible rate. We are causing a global climate change that is going to be absolutely devastating to the coral reefs. Science is unable to keep up with our industrial society. We are destroying species faster than we can classify them. We are destroying the food chain faster than we can understand it. The politicians are over in Copenhagen talking about climate change now – but there are other issues as well."
While reading John F. Richards’ book The Unending Frontier (2003), I could not help but think of Avatar. Some of the historical processes of the early modern world presented by Richards are also present in Cameron’s 22nd century lush earth-like moon Pandora, which is being attacked by an American mining corporation. Both Richards and Cameron highlight the settlement of the frontiers, which has a strong impact on the environment and on native peoples. Richards accounts for the entrepreneurial spirit of the Western European societies taken by maritime achievements in shipping, mapmaking, navigation, and global exploration, which leads to the settlement of far off places around the globe and subsequently to the destruction of their ecosystems and native populations. Cameron, in the same fashion, accounts for the establishment of a futuristic biotechnology that allows scientists to grow Pandora’s native people’s-human hybrid bodies called avatars, which are operated via mental link by genetically matching humans, which facilitate research of Pandora's biosphere for harnessing its natural resources, with total disregard to its native peoples, the Na’vis. The powerful RDA Corporation in Cameron’s film wants to mine a valuable mineral called unobtanium in Pandora, much like the VOC (the Dutch East India Company), for example, wanted to tap natural resources in Africa, Asia, and the Americas in the 16th, 17th, and 18th centuries. Richards highlights the expansion of the frontiers, with its negative impact on the environment due to intensive resource extraction and land use, which was often very detrimental to the ecosystems and the native peoples. For Richards, by writing the history of these lands, how they came to be conquered and exploited, he is shaping identity and subsequent action. For him, we “desperately need a shared global identity that derives from knowledge and wisdom about a common human past” (2003: xiii). For filmmaker James Cameron, his blockbuster Avatar, which depicts a world of stunning natural beauty that is threatened with destruction, is a cautionary tale about our own environment.
The Dutch with their East India Company (VOC), the Spanish with their annual fleets (Carrera de Indias) and the Portuguese with their colonization enterprise (Captaincies) occupied far off lands, exploited resources, enslaved, catechized and killed hundreds of indigenous populations. The similarities in Richards’ chapters abound. Extracting natural resources, cultivating land intensively for profit, and converting the native populations were some of the reasons for much of the undertakings of the Dutch, the Spanish, and the Portuguese in the early modern world. While the Dutch gained converts to its Reformed Church, the Portuguese and Spanish sought converts to the Church of Rome. The devastating effect on the indigenous groups was unprecedented, with an estimate loss of 5 to 6 million native people in the Americas alone. The environmental impact that the Europeans caused on the lands that they conquered was such that much of the natural resources and the native populations, often killed by pandemics, were completely transformed or wiped out by the time they left. The Portuguese changed one-million-square kilometers of Atlantic forest in Brazil; the Spanish completely altered the landscapes of Mexico, Hispaniola and the West Indies islands; and the Dutch managed to deplete nearly all the larger fauna of the entire Cape region and wipe out the vast deer herds of the Western Taiwan plain.
Expansion of territory is highlighted in several of Richards’ chapters. He analyzes the frontier settlement undertaken by the Russians, for instance, who for centuries acquired territories, actively changing the habitats in ways that the pastoral nomads had not done before. The tsar and patriarch of Moscow, much like the Crown in Portugal and Spain, and the Dutch Republic, also aimed at converting their conquered population. The conquered Muslims, by the Russians, were forced to accept Eastern Orthodox Christianity. Different from what the Western Europeans had done in the Americas, Africa, and Asia, the Russian settlers did not clear, at least at first, most of the forests they acquired. They left some of it standing as a defensive mechanism against attackers. Later, however, with the rise of settler population, these forests were inevitably reduced. Similar to what had happened to the native peoples in the Americas, Africa, and Asia, once the frontier was conquered by Russian settlers, no longer could the local peasants escape serfdom.
Richards also points out that early modern China, much like Russia, expanded its internal frontiers of settlement and intensified its land use in spite of adverse climate conditions in certain regions. Chinese expansion also had an adverse impact on the environment, with widespread deforestation through central and southern China, which resulted in severe consequences. Much like most of the other stories approached by Richards, the indigenous peoples of China also lost ground to the frontier settlers, the Han migrants. Also, similar to most of the other settlement stories, China’s forests were not able to keep up with the demands for industrial and domestic fuel.
One unique story of the early modern era presented by Richards is of the Tokugawa period in Japan (1603-1867), a time of internal peace, political stability, and economic growth. Richards argues that “the social discipline imposed by the Tokugawa regime at all levels made it possible to conserve forest and other resources and to regenerate resources” (2003: 149). He points out that literacy was unquestionably a great asset to the dissemination of the technical and moral information to the population. This asset, however, was missing in most of the enterprises carried out abroad by the Europeans during that same period. The Portuguese Crown, for instance, was not interested in disseminating literacy in Brazil. Historian Thomas Skidmore has argued that,
The Portuguese Crown prohibited printing presses from operating in Brazil, with the result that no books, newspapers, or magazines were ever published in colonial Brazil. Brazilians had to get their university education in Coimbra, Portugal, and their only hope to publish was in Europe. The absence of the printing press in colonial Brazil was unique in colonial Latin America. So in this respect, colonial Brazil suffered from a singular defect: the absence of two institutions, the printing press and the university, essential for economic development. The latter condition persisted long after independence; the first Brazilian university was not founded until 1932 .
Still in regard to the Tokugawa period, sociologist Robert N. Bellah asserts that “there were rationalizing tendencies in Japanese religion that contributed to Japan’s economic and political rationalization starting during the Tokugawa period (1600-1868)” . For Bellah “Japan contained a ‘functional analogue’ to the Protestant ethic. Both Buddhism and Confucianism contained ‘this-worldly’ or ‘inner-worldly’ ethics emphasizing activism and achievement in the secular world”, which for Bellah was the same type of religious orientation that Max Weber (1904) presents in his book The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism to explain the rise of modern capitalism. Perhaps the religious ethics contributed to the conservation measures taken by the Tokugawa regime to protect and nurture state forests.
Six hundred and fifty years separate the beginning of the early modern era -- when Western European nations started an expansion enterprise that irreversibly and severely impacted the environment and the lives of native peoples in far off lands -- from the fictitious world of Pandora created by director James Cameron. The plight of the Na’vis and their land of Pandora, despite distant in time and space, is not much different from that of the indigenous population around the globe that were assaulted by Europeans under the banner of Christianity and development. One difference, however, remains between these two stories, besides one being fictitious and the other real: The Na’vis are saved by Jake Sully, an American former marine, who falls in love with a native woman and her culture and rejects the RDA’s agenda to conquer Pandora. Unfortunately, during the European expansion of the early modern era, not even the Spanish Dominican priest Bartolomé de las Casas, considered the defender and apostle to the Indians, was able to save the indigenous population of South America. His ideas had little effect on changing Spanish attitudes towards the natives and their lands. The lust of the conquistadores’ for gold and other resources was stronger than the recognition of religious or moral justice. Unfortunately, there was no hero in Richards’ stories to save the environment and the native populations.
--
Neda Bezerra
Geographically-Integrated History Laboratory
Historical Resources Management
Idaho State University
Pocatello, ID.
"The point is that we are devastating habitat and biodiversity at a terrible rate. We are causing a global climate change that is going to be absolutely devastating to the coral reefs. Science is unable to keep up with our industrial society. We are destroying species faster than we can classify them. We are destroying the food chain faster than we can understand it. The politicians are over in Copenhagen talking about climate change now – but there are other issues as well."
While reading John F. Richards’ book The Unending Frontier (2003), I could not help but think of Avatar. Some of the historical processes of the early modern world presented by Richards are also present in Cameron’s 22nd century lush earth-like moon Pandora, which is being attacked by an American mining corporation. Both Richards and Cameron highlight the settlement of the frontiers, which has a strong impact on the environment and on native peoples. Richards accounts for the entrepreneurial spirit of the Western European societies taken by maritime achievements in shipping, mapmaking, navigation, and global exploration, which leads to the settlement of far off places around the globe and subsequently to the destruction of their ecosystems and native populations. Cameron, in the same fashion, accounts for the establishment of a futuristic biotechnology that allows scientists to grow Pandora’s native people’s-human hybrid bodies called avatars, which are operated via mental link by genetically matching humans, which facilitate research of Pandora's biosphere for harnessing its natural resources, with total disregard to its native peoples, the Na’vis. The powerful RDA Corporation in Cameron’s film wants to mine a valuable mineral called unobtanium in Pandora, much like the VOC (the Dutch East India Company), for example, wanted to tap natural resources in Africa, Asia, and the Americas in the 16th, 17th, and 18th centuries. Richards highlights the expansion of the frontiers, with its negative impact on the environment due to intensive resource extraction and land use, which was often very detrimental to the ecosystems and the native peoples. For Richards, by writing the history of these lands, how they came to be conquered and exploited, he is shaping identity and subsequent action. For him, we “desperately need a shared global identity that derives from knowledge and wisdom about a common human past” (2003: xiii). For filmmaker James Cameron, his blockbuster Avatar, which depicts a world of stunning natural beauty that is threatened with destruction, is a cautionary tale about our own environment.
The Dutch with their East India Company (VOC), the Spanish with their annual fleets (Carrera de Indias) and the Portuguese with their colonization enterprise (Captaincies) occupied far off lands, exploited resources, enslaved, catechized and killed hundreds of indigenous populations. The similarities in Richards’ chapters abound. Extracting natural resources, cultivating land intensively for profit, and converting the native populations were some of the reasons for much of the undertakings of the Dutch, the Spanish, and the Portuguese in the early modern world. While the Dutch gained converts to its Reformed Church, the Portuguese and Spanish sought converts to the Church of Rome. The devastating effect on the indigenous groups was unprecedented, with an estimate loss of 5 to 6 million native people in the Americas alone. The environmental impact that the Europeans caused on the lands that they conquered was such that much of the natural resources and the native populations, often killed by pandemics, were completely transformed or wiped out by the time they left. The Portuguese changed one-million-square kilometers of Atlantic forest in Brazil; the Spanish completely altered the landscapes of Mexico, Hispaniola and the West Indies islands; and the Dutch managed to deplete nearly all the larger fauna of the entire Cape region and wipe out the vast deer herds of the Western Taiwan plain.
Expansion of territory is highlighted in several of Richards’ chapters. He analyzes the frontier settlement undertaken by the Russians, for instance, who for centuries acquired territories, actively changing the habitats in ways that the pastoral nomads had not done before. The tsar and patriarch of Moscow, much like the Crown in Portugal and Spain, and the Dutch Republic, also aimed at converting their conquered population. The conquered Muslims, by the Russians, were forced to accept Eastern Orthodox Christianity. Different from what the Western Europeans had done in the Americas, Africa, and Asia, the Russian settlers did not clear, at least at first, most of the forests they acquired. They left some of it standing as a defensive mechanism against attackers. Later, however, with the rise of settler population, these forests were inevitably reduced. Similar to what had happened to the native peoples in the Americas, Africa, and Asia, once the frontier was conquered by Russian settlers, no longer could the local peasants escape serfdom.
Richards also points out that early modern China, much like Russia, expanded its internal frontiers of settlement and intensified its land use in spite of adverse climate conditions in certain regions. Chinese expansion also had an adverse impact on the environment, with widespread deforestation through central and southern China, which resulted in severe consequences. Much like most of the other stories approached by Richards, the indigenous peoples of China also lost ground to the frontier settlers, the Han migrants. Also, similar to most of the other settlement stories, China’s forests were not able to keep up with the demands for industrial and domestic fuel.
One unique story of the early modern era presented by Richards is of the Tokugawa period in Japan (1603-1867), a time of internal peace, political stability, and economic growth. Richards argues that “the social discipline imposed by the Tokugawa regime at all levels made it possible to conserve forest and other resources and to regenerate resources” (2003: 149). He points out that literacy was unquestionably a great asset to the dissemination of the technical and moral information to the population. This asset, however, was missing in most of the enterprises carried out abroad by the Europeans during that same period. The Portuguese Crown, for instance, was not interested in disseminating literacy in Brazil. Historian Thomas Skidmore has argued that,
The Portuguese Crown prohibited printing presses from operating in Brazil, with the result that no books, newspapers, or magazines were ever published in colonial Brazil. Brazilians had to get their university education in Coimbra, Portugal, and their only hope to publish was in Europe. The absence of the printing press in colonial Brazil was unique in colonial Latin America. So in this respect, colonial Brazil suffered from a singular defect: the absence of two institutions, the printing press and the university, essential for economic development. The latter condition persisted long after independence; the first Brazilian university was not founded until 1932 .
Still in regard to the Tokugawa period, sociologist Robert N. Bellah asserts that “there were rationalizing tendencies in Japanese religion that contributed to Japan’s economic and political rationalization starting during the Tokugawa period (1600-1868)” . For Bellah “Japan contained a ‘functional analogue’ to the Protestant ethic. Both Buddhism and Confucianism contained ‘this-worldly’ or ‘inner-worldly’ ethics emphasizing activism and achievement in the secular world”, which for Bellah was the same type of religious orientation that Max Weber (1904) presents in his book The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism to explain the rise of modern capitalism. Perhaps the religious ethics contributed to the conservation measures taken by the Tokugawa regime to protect and nurture state forests.
Six hundred and fifty years separate the beginning of the early modern era -- when Western European nations started an expansion enterprise that irreversibly and severely impacted the environment and the lives of native peoples in far off lands -- from the fictitious world of Pandora created by director James Cameron. The plight of the Na’vis and their land of Pandora, despite distant in time and space, is not much different from that of the indigenous population around the globe that were assaulted by Europeans under the banner of Christianity and development. One difference, however, remains between these two stories, besides one being fictitious and the other real: The Na’vis are saved by Jake Sully, an American former marine, who falls in love with a native woman and her culture and rejects the RDA’s agenda to conquer Pandora. Unfortunately, during the European expansion of the early modern era, not even the Spanish Dominican priest Bartolomé de las Casas, considered the defender and apostle to the Indians, was able to save the indigenous population of South America. His ideas had little effect on changing Spanish attitudes towards the natives and their lands. The lust of the conquistadores’ for gold and other resources was stronger than the recognition of religious or moral justice. Unfortunately, there was no hero in Richards’ stories to save the environment and the native populations.
--
Neda Bezerra
Geographically-Integrated History Laboratory
Historical Resources Management
Idaho State University
Pocatello, ID.
The Sable, the Beaver, and the Deer: Actors in the Development of Trade in the Early Modern World.
The early modern world -- the time that follows the Middle Ages, from the late fifteenth century to the early nineteenth century -- has long been recognized as a period when nations, taking advantage of maritime improvements, established new links around the world, sustained contacts with previously isolated populations, intensively exploited natural resources, and established trade routes, consolidating the start of a true global economy. The exceptional circulation of people and ethos that marked this era was driven by an equally never before seen circulation of goods that connected the world through production, commerce, and consumption and also transformed the landscape and the native peoples of previously secluded areas. The success of these large scale enterprises, carried out by early modern states in Europe, Asia, and colonial states in the Americas and Africa, rested mostly on the power of the states, which sought to maximize profits on the far off lands under their control. The historiography of this early global age is, therefore, one that has dealt largely with broad trends of maritime mobility, conquest, frontiers settlements, large scale trade, intensified land use and extraction of previously unused and often unknown natural resources, as well as decimation of native populations by epidemics. The sable, the beaver, and the deer became main actors in the development of this global era.
All the regions presented by John F. Richards in his book The Unending Frontier (2005) share several similar trends in their environmental history. However, the hunt for and trade of fur and skin in Siberia, Eastern North America, and Taiwan during the early modern age share some startling similarities. By the 1500s these three regions remained open to exploration, conquest, and exploitation. They retained a very rich fauna and flora, which, during the next three hundred years, were intensively exploited by private and public undertakings.
In the late sixteenth century the Russian state along with private groups of fur trappers and traders started to explore Siberia. The Russian killing power was much superior to what the native Siberians could endure. Once conquered the natives had to obey the tsar’s authority and deliver a specified number of furs and pelts as payment of annual taxes established by the Russian state. The further the Russians went, the more they conquered and submitted the natives to their ruling power. The lure of more and more furs, especially sable’s, pushed the Russian frontiersmen eastward with their banner of conquest and domination. The native Siberians slowly but surely had to swear oath to the Russian authority. Effective resistance to the Russians was impossible since the native groups lacked centralizing state structures and organization power. Had the indigenous peoples of Siberia been more and better organized, perhaps it would have taken longer for them to be conquered. These native populations were also weakened by diseases that were foreign to them, such as smallpox, measles, and venereal diseases. Besides the epidemics, the natives were hit hard by alcoholism, which contributed to the breaking of their social fabric. Also, Russian brutality took a hard too on them. The Russian expansion over Siberia, besides bringing about the depletion of the sable population and other furbearers, destroyed the Siberian communities, turning the natives that had not been killed by the epidemics, very dependent on the Russian settlers.
Unfortunately, a similar story of conquest is that of Eastern North America. As Richards (2005, 463) explains, “Much of the early impetus for maritime travel to North America came from the profits to be made from hunting, killing, processing, and shipping animal skins back to Europe.” The North American beaver, much like the sable in Siberia, became the most valuable furbearer of the New World and for three hundred years demand for beaver hats in Europe propelled the hunting of this most industrious rodent, known for helping shape the landscape of North America through its constructions of dams.
Despite the fact that the French, the British, and the Dutch in North America were not as brutal to the natives as the Russians were in Siberia and did not demand any tax payment from them, the fur trade enterprise of North America shared several common trends with the settlement of Siberia, brought forward by the hunt for fur in that region. First, similar to the sable’s fate in Siberia, the demands established by the fur trade in North America depleted the beaver population to near extinction in the North, which had a profound impact on the landscape. It also depleted the deer herds in the South. Second, the contagious diseases brought to the New World by the Europeans killed thousands of indigenous people and weakened many more. The introduction of tobacco and alcohol also helped to weaken and demoralize Indian societies, tearing apart their social fabric, in a pattern similar to that found among the native populations of Siberia. Alcohol also caused depression among the Indians, making them even more vulnerable to the European advances. The cultural and social devastation suffered by the North American Indians was nearly identical to that faced by the native Siberians. While the native Siberians developed a need for bread, became addicted to alcohol and tobacco, and relied on firearms introduced by the Russians, the North American Indians developed a need for muskets, balls, powder, kettles, knives, hatches, needles, scissors, pipes, and other goods as well as a taste for tobacco, rum and brandy. The North American fur trade redefined Native American’s relationships with the wildlife, the forest, and their spiritual world. It made them more and more dependent on Europeans and their goods and also less able to resist invasion of their lands. In addition, dissemination of firearms brought much deadliness to the Indian population. Similar to the plight of the native Siberians, the advancing European settlement frontier set the final blow to most Indian groups in North American.
On the other side of the globe, in Asia, set the isolated island of Taiwan, off the China coast, which during the sixteenth century was covered with thick vegetation and was sparsely populated by native Taiwanese descendents of Neolithic Austronesian settlers, who had migrated to the island from China as early as 4,000 B.C.E. After much effort, in 1624 the Dutch East India Company (VOC) was able to monopolize the profitable trade in that region and establish Fort Zeelandia in Taiwan in order take control of the native Taiwanese and the island’s resources. Richards (2005, 95) explains that “where strong, confident regimes were in place […] VOC representatives became humble traders content to petition for whatever privileges they could obtain.” This was certainly not the case in Taiwan since the island was so sparsely populated and its native peoples not well organized, much like the Siberians in the Northern hemisphere. Thus, within only twenty years the Dutch were ruling most of Taiwan and running a very intensive business of deerskins, which were exported to Japan in great numbers as well as to other parts of the world. Even though the Taiwanese aborigines felt a heavy impact from the Dutch colonial policies, they were not struck by contagious diseases like the native Siberians and North Americans were, perhaps due to their previous contact to other foreign people. In a pattern similar to that found in Siberia and North America, the new rulers of Taiwan tried very hard to destroy the aborigine’s social fabric by introducing Christianity to them, challenging the spiritual authority of Taiwanese female shamans and chastising idol worshipers, for instance. Besides interfering with their original belief system, the Dutch also changed Taiwanese horticulture and established tax collection. In 1661 the Chinese took over Taiwan and started ruling over the island, putting even more pressure on the native Taiwanese to sell deerskins. By the mid-1700s the aboriginal culture had been severely damaged. The Chinese had overhunted the deer population and inflicted much destruction on their habitat. In less than two hundred years the vast deer herds of the early seventeenth century had been totally wiped out and the indigenous peoples of Taiwan that had not assimilated Chinese culture had to move out of their original environment upwards to the mountains.
The sable, the beaver, and the deer may have seemed unlikely actors in the development of trade in the early modern age, but as new links around the world were established and a global economy emerged, these animals became important components of the world’s economic and geographic expansion. The fur and skin trade, which centered, in large part, on these three animals, became a mechanism by which Europeans and Asians advanced into and settled new frontiers. Much like other natural resources exploited during the early modern age, these animals played a very important role in the expansion of territory and global trade. Unfortunately, they were the epicenter of much destruction of native populations and natural habitats.
--
Neda Bezerra
Geographically-Integrated History Laboratory
Historical Resources Management
Idaho State University
Pocatello, ID.
All the regions presented by John F. Richards in his book The Unending Frontier (2005) share several similar trends in their environmental history. However, the hunt for and trade of fur and skin in Siberia, Eastern North America, and Taiwan during the early modern age share some startling similarities. By the 1500s these three regions remained open to exploration, conquest, and exploitation. They retained a very rich fauna and flora, which, during the next three hundred years, were intensively exploited by private and public undertakings.
In the late sixteenth century the Russian state along with private groups of fur trappers and traders started to explore Siberia. The Russian killing power was much superior to what the native Siberians could endure. Once conquered the natives had to obey the tsar’s authority and deliver a specified number of furs and pelts as payment of annual taxes established by the Russian state. The further the Russians went, the more they conquered and submitted the natives to their ruling power. The lure of more and more furs, especially sable’s, pushed the Russian frontiersmen eastward with their banner of conquest and domination. The native Siberians slowly but surely had to swear oath to the Russian authority. Effective resistance to the Russians was impossible since the native groups lacked centralizing state structures and organization power. Had the indigenous peoples of Siberia been more and better organized, perhaps it would have taken longer for them to be conquered. These native populations were also weakened by diseases that were foreign to them, such as smallpox, measles, and venereal diseases. Besides the epidemics, the natives were hit hard by alcoholism, which contributed to the breaking of their social fabric. Also, Russian brutality took a hard too on them. The Russian expansion over Siberia, besides bringing about the depletion of the sable population and other furbearers, destroyed the Siberian communities, turning the natives that had not been killed by the epidemics, very dependent on the Russian settlers.
Unfortunately, a similar story of conquest is that of Eastern North America. As Richards (2005, 463) explains, “Much of the early impetus for maritime travel to North America came from the profits to be made from hunting, killing, processing, and shipping animal skins back to Europe.” The North American beaver, much like the sable in Siberia, became the most valuable furbearer of the New World and for three hundred years demand for beaver hats in Europe propelled the hunting of this most industrious rodent, known for helping shape the landscape of North America through its constructions of dams.
Despite the fact that the French, the British, and the Dutch in North America were not as brutal to the natives as the Russians were in Siberia and did not demand any tax payment from them, the fur trade enterprise of North America shared several common trends with the settlement of Siberia, brought forward by the hunt for fur in that region. First, similar to the sable’s fate in Siberia, the demands established by the fur trade in North America depleted the beaver population to near extinction in the North, which had a profound impact on the landscape. It also depleted the deer herds in the South. Second, the contagious diseases brought to the New World by the Europeans killed thousands of indigenous people and weakened many more. The introduction of tobacco and alcohol also helped to weaken and demoralize Indian societies, tearing apart their social fabric, in a pattern similar to that found among the native populations of Siberia. Alcohol also caused depression among the Indians, making them even more vulnerable to the European advances. The cultural and social devastation suffered by the North American Indians was nearly identical to that faced by the native Siberians. While the native Siberians developed a need for bread, became addicted to alcohol and tobacco, and relied on firearms introduced by the Russians, the North American Indians developed a need for muskets, balls, powder, kettles, knives, hatches, needles, scissors, pipes, and other goods as well as a taste for tobacco, rum and brandy. The North American fur trade redefined Native American’s relationships with the wildlife, the forest, and their spiritual world. It made them more and more dependent on Europeans and their goods and also less able to resist invasion of their lands. In addition, dissemination of firearms brought much deadliness to the Indian population. Similar to the plight of the native Siberians, the advancing European settlement frontier set the final blow to most Indian groups in North American.
On the other side of the globe, in Asia, set the isolated island of Taiwan, off the China coast, which during the sixteenth century was covered with thick vegetation and was sparsely populated by native Taiwanese descendents of Neolithic Austronesian settlers, who had migrated to the island from China as early as 4,000 B.C.E. After much effort, in 1624 the Dutch East India Company (VOC) was able to monopolize the profitable trade in that region and establish Fort Zeelandia in Taiwan in order take control of the native Taiwanese and the island’s resources. Richards (2005, 95) explains that “where strong, confident regimes were in place […] VOC representatives became humble traders content to petition for whatever privileges they could obtain.” This was certainly not the case in Taiwan since the island was so sparsely populated and its native peoples not well organized, much like the Siberians in the Northern hemisphere. Thus, within only twenty years the Dutch were ruling most of Taiwan and running a very intensive business of deerskins, which were exported to Japan in great numbers as well as to other parts of the world. Even though the Taiwanese aborigines felt a heavy impact from the Dutch colonial policies, they were not struck by contagious diseases like the native Siberians and North Americans were, perhaps due to their previous contact to other foreign people. In a pattern similar to that found in Siberia and North America, the new rulers of Taiwan tried very hard to destroy the aborigine’s social fabric by introducing Christianity to them, challenging the spiritual authority of Taiwanese female shamans and chastising idol worshipers, for instance. Besides interfering with their original belief system, the Dutch also changed Taiwanese horticulture and established tax collection. In 1661 the Chinese took over Taiwan and started ruling over the island, putting even more pressure on the native Taiwanese to sell deerskins. By the mid-1700s the aboriginal culture had been severely damaged. The Chinese had overhunted the deer population and inflicted much destruction on their habitat. In less than two hundred years the vast deer herds of the early seventeenth century had been totally wiped out and the indigenous peoples of Taiwan that had not assimilated Chinese culture had to move out of their original environment upwards to the mountains.
The sable, the beaver, and the deer may have seemed unlikely actors in the development of trade in the early modern age, but as new links around the world were established and a global economy emerged, these animals became important components of the world’s economic and geographic expansion. The fur and skin trade, which centered, in large part, on these three animals, became a mechanism by which Europeans and Asians advanced into and settled new frontiers. Much like other natural resources exploited during the early modern age, these animals played a very important role in the expansion of territory and global trade. Unfortunately, they were the epicenter of much destruction of native populations and natural habitats.
--
Neda Bezerra
Geographically-Integrated History Laboratory
Historical Resources Management
Idaho State University
Pocatello, ID.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)









